Is transsexualism unnatural?

February 26, 2011 at 11:15 pm Leave a comment

The short answer is I don’t know. But how useful is that question anyhow? I mean, is it natural to have a caesarean section, wear clothes or drive cars? And yet we do them. The question is only meaningful if we clarify what we mean by “natural”. And it is only a criticism if we interpret that which is unnatural, as negative. The dictionary is as good a place as any to begin our search for answers. Here a few definitions for “natural”:

  • functioning or occurring in a normal way; lacking abnormalities or deficiencies; “it’s the natural thing to happen”; “natural immunity”; “a grandparent’s natural affection for a grandchild”

If by “normal” we mean that which is true for most, then yes, transsexualism is abnormal. We are a small minority – by today’s statistics less than 1% of the general population. How we function covers a spectrum. Some are able to live out happy, satisfactory lives, find satisfying employment and build families just like their so-called normal neighbours. Others live on the verge of poverty and face crushing rejection from families, friends, employers and partners. Our lives are at the mercy of the acceptance of those around us. If we are granted the space to exist, we do so happily. But we can just as easily be pushed into isolation. Whether or not our condition is a deficiency is debatable. It is, perhaps, no more a deficiency than being homosexual is. However, homosexuals do not normally require hormone replacement therapy and surgery to feel comfortable in their own skin. That is where transsexuals diverge from their queer cousins. The medical component of the transsexual journey places us more on a par with those who suffer physical disabilities. Of course, one might argue than anyone with a physical disability could also be classified as “unnatural”, as they do not function in a normal way. And yet few people would go around claiming that a paraplegic lacks the right to exist because she or he is unnatural?

Let’s try another “natural” definition:

  • being talented through inherited qualities; “a natural leader”; “a born musician”; “an innate talent”

And this, of course, is the crux of the matter. Is transsexualism a condition we are born with, or is it a learned behaviour, a lifestyle choice, the symptom of bad family upbringing? Does its secret lie in the body or the brain — are we programmed to be different? The nature versus nurture debate puzzles me. After all, can we really separate environment from biology? Our biology, our innate traits, may shape our personalities — but there is also evidence to suggest that our environment can trigger biological, yes even genetic, changes (See Why Your DNA Isn’t Your Destiny [Time Magazine, Jan 06, 2010]). Arguing about the primacy of biology or environment is a little like arguing about which came first: the chicken or the egg. I have yet to encounter a satisfactory answer. Whether transsexualism is genetically or environmentally driven does not, in my opinion, render it more natural or less so.

Then there is this:

  • lifelike: free from artificiality; “a lifelike pose”; “a natural reaction”

Some who believe in the unnaturalness of the trans experience claim that you are what you were born as. To change one’s gender is to become an artificial man or woman; and that is never, in the eyes of those who hold this view, the same as the real thing. To them, I can only ever be a sad imitation of a real man. While it is true that my body does not produce sperm, and that I did not go through puberty with my male peers, instead having to endure female puberty and then male puberty in my early twenties when I began hormone therapy, I do not believe my experience invalidates me as a man. If anything it gives me a unique perspective on the world, on how we gender our children and on the way we are terrified of that which we do not understand.

And that is what it boils down to for me. I don’t understand, not really, why transsexuals exist. But I am no longer terrified of my difference, and do not feel the need to hide myself from the world. Do I sometimes feel inadequate as a man, as a human being? Absolutely – but so do many so-called normal men. Do I sometimes envy those whose born sex matches their gender? Definitely. Do I feel that I am deficient, disfigured, or artificial? Absolutely not. I believe that I am here for a reason. Unnatural or not.

hy Your DNA Isn’t Your Destiny


Entry filed under: Gender, Masculinity, Sexuality, Transgender.

This I believe self-hate and the transsexual

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 7 other followers

Recent Posts


February 2011
« Jan   Mar »

%d bloggers like this: